Showing posts with label property of the estate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label property of the estate. Show all posts

Monday, July 7, 2014

As it applies to property of the estate, the Bankruptcy Code is intended to apply to property located anywhere...including outside of the U.S. (9th Cir. 2014) - Published

This is the second case which the 9th recently decided in this matter.

The Diaz Defendants concede that they waived any objection they could have
raised under Stern v. Marshall, 131 S. Ct. 2594 (2011), to the bankruptcy court’s entry of final judgment. See Exec. Benefits Ins. Agency v. Arkison, 702 F.3d 553, 566–70 (9th Cir. 2012), aff’d on other grounds, 573 U.S. ___ (2014).

(interesting that the parties conceded that they could waive the objection)


The panel affirmed the district court’s affirmance of the bankruptcy court’s judgment (1) invalidating the transfer to Alejandro Diaz-Barba and Martha Barba de la Torre (the

“Diaz Defendants”) of a Mexican coastal villa owned by debtors Jerry and Donna Icenhower and (2) requiring the Diaz Defendants to transfer the property to Kismet Acquisition, LLC, for the benefit of debtors’ bankruptcy estate.


The debtors transferred the property to H&G, a shell company they had purchased. After the debtors filed for bankruptcy, H&G sold the property to the Diaz Defendants. The bankruptcy trustee filed a fraudulent conveyance action seeking to avoid the sale of the villa to H&G as a fraudulent

pre-petition transfer. The bankruptcy trustee also filed an action seeking to avoid the sale to the Diaz Defendants on the basis that H&G was the debtors’ alter ego and that the sale was an unauthorized postpetition transfer.


The panel affirmed the bankruptcy court’s judgment on the postpetition transfer action. It held that the Diaz Defendants had waived any objection they could have raised to the bankruptcy court’s Article III authority to enter final judgment. The panel held that since the bankruptcy court’s judgment for Kismet was the same in both actions, the panel’s judgment rendered the fraudulent conveyance action moot.


The panel held that the bankruptcy court did not err by exercising jurisdiction over Mexican land. The panel held that the local action doctrine was preempted by statute and that 28 U.S.C. § 1334(e) granted the bankruptcy court  exclusive in rem jurisdiction over the villa interest. The panel also held that the bankruptcy court did not improperly apply  U.S. law extraterritorially because Congress intended extraterritorial application of the Bankruptcy Code as it applies to property of the estate. Given the bankruptcy court’s ruling that H&G was the debtors’ alter ego and its substantive consolidation of H&G with the bankruptcy estate,  the villa interest was property of the estate as of the petition date.


The panel held that the bankruptcy court did not abuse its discretion by failing to honor the contractual selection of a Mexican forum. The bankruptcy court also did not err by declining to abstain from ordering recovery of the property based on international comity because there was no true conflict of law. The panel held that Mexico was not a
necessary and indispensable party. Distinguishing In re Tippett, 542 F.3d 684 (9th Cir. 2008), the panel held that the
bankruptcy court did not err in applying U.S. law instead of Mexican law to determine whether the Diaz Defendants were good faith purchasers. Finally, the panel held that
bankruptcy court did not clearly err in finding that Martha Barba de la Torre purchased the villa in bad faith


In re Icenhower - 9th Cir. 2014

Tuesday, November 5, 2013

Chapter 13 - Property of the Estate INCLUDES Post-Petition Assets - (4th Cir Published)

In a Chapter 13 case, post-petition assets such as a personal injury claim and even an inheritance is property of the Estate.  The 4th Circuit was faced with an inheritance which arose more than 180 days after filing.  The Debtor contended it was not property of the Estate and the Trustee argued otherwise.  The Court found that it was property of the Estate.

In re Carroll - 4th Cir. Published 13-1024

Also, see the 5th Circuit case which was mentioned in this blog

Continuing Duty to Disclose Assets in a Chapter 13

Tuesday, October 29, 2013

Property Abandoned is Stil Subject to the Automatic Stay Until the Stay is Terminated (9th Cir. BAP Published)

Once property is abandoned the property is no longer property of the Bankruptcy Estate as it reverts in the Debtor as of the date of the filing of the petition (just like no bankruptcy was filed).  However, the property is still subject to the automatic stay under 362(a)(5).  By utilizing statutory construction, the BAP found that despite the abandonment and the Bankruptcy Court's belief that the stay is terminated upon abandonment, the property was still subject to the stay. An interesting and well developed decision.

In re Gasprom 9th Cir. BAP